Marlins 3-Peat In Closest of Finishes

By Dean Holzwarth
Special for MHSAA.com

November 23, 2019

HOLLAND – This weekend’s MHSAA Lower Peninsula Division 1 Girls Swimming & Diving Final came down to a back-and-forth tussle between Farmington Hills Mercy and Ann Arbor Pioneer.

In the end, the winner was decided by less than a point.

Mercy collected its third consecutive Finals championship with a thrilling win Saturday afternoon at Holland Aquatic Center. The Marlins edged Pioneer, 298-297.5. Saline took third (197.5), while Rockford placed fourth (179.5).

“I’m getting too old for this,” Mercy coach Mike Venos joked. “But I’m never going to complain about a state championship and these girls held it together mentally, which is something we’ve been working on with this senior group for four years. Just learning to control the things in their control, and that’s coming in here swimming fast and diving well.

“Pioneer swam fantastic today, and if it would’ve been a tie for both of us that would’ve been great because honestly, they deserve it as much as we do.”

Top-ranked Pioneer was seeking its first team championship since a string of nine in a row ended in 2008.

The Pioneers won the 200-yard freestyle relay (1:34.75) and the 400 free relay (3:25.31).

“Going into today we decided we were going to take it one race at a time, and we were going to try and do everything we could,” Pioneer coach Stefanie Kerska said. “We were going to control our controllables, and we did that really well.

“I’m super proud of the way they handled themselves in a tough moment to be in, and they handled themselves very gracefully with a lot of grit. That’s all you can ask of them.” 

Mercy junior Greta Gidley won the team’s lone individual championship. She raced to victory in the 100 free in a time of 50.53 seconds and bested Ann Arbor Pioneer’s Lucy Mehraban (50.86) by the slimmest of margins. 

“I woke up this morning at 6 a.m. because I couldn’t go back to sleep, and all I could think about was this is a dream team and I will never be on a team as great as this one,” Gidley said. “The whole time, there was never a doubt in my mind that we could not do it, that we couldn’t win it again.

“This team is closer than it’s ever been before, and I think that has helped. We’re all best friends, and we train together and dive together. That just makes it that much better.”

The Marlins won last year’s Final by 11 points over Harrison-Farmington.

“I thought last year was close, and this was even closer now,” senior Julia Coffman said. “I couldn’t imagine doing this with any other people, and it’s like a dream. This is the most incredible group I’ve ever been around, and I’m savoring this moment.

“We train with Pioneer, and we are close with them and they put their hearts into it. They are a great team, but today we were just a little better.”

Hudsonville senior Claire Tuttle pulled off the three-peat in the 100 breaststroke and nearly set a new meet record in the race. Tuttle clocked a time of 1:00.79, nearly besting Miranda Tucker, who swam a 1:00.56 in 2014. 

Tuttle also won the 50 free in 22.80 seconds.

“My expectations were to just do the best I could and support my team,” Tuttle said. “I really wanted to go for Miranda Tucker’s state record, but she’s also insanely fast and it’s an honor to be that close to her.

“I didn’t expect to do as well as I did in the 50 free, but that was insane, and I just feel beyond blessed that I’ve been able to be a part of such a supportive team and to make these friendships that have lasted throughout high school and have gotten me through so much. It’s sad to see it all go, but I’m excited for the new beginning (at the University of Michigan ).”

Grand Haven senior Kathryn Ackerman ended her high school career in style by capturing a pair of individual titles to finish with five at the Finals.

She won her third straight 200 individual medley (1:57.61) championship while also coming out victorious in the 100 back (54.70).

She also helped her team finish runner-up in the 400 free relay.

“I was pretty happy with all my swims,” Ackerman said. “It was a little bittersweet to go into my last meet, so there were a lot of emotions. I was just hoping to go out there and have fun and get close to my best times, and I was. It was fun to have that comeback at the end and have that be my last swim as a Buccaneer.”

Grand Ledge senior Lola Mull became a three-time winner in the 500 free with a time of 4:55.02, while Ann Arbor Skyline senior Allison Haak won the 200 free (1:50.65) and Northville freshman Emily Roden won the 100 fly (55.43).

Ann Arbor Huron junior diver Annie Costello avenged her runner-up finish at last year’s Final and put forth a dominating effort with a winning score of 424.40.

Top-seeded Rockford (Sara Kraus, Masy Folcik, Rachel Gamm and Ashley Lund) held off Pioneer to win the 200 medley relay (1:42.40).

Click for full results.

PHOTOS: (Top) Farmington Hills Mercy cheers on its 400 freestyle relay, which finished third to give the team a ½-point overall championship win. (Middle) Hudsonville’s Claire Tuttle swims to her third-straight 100 breaststroke championship. (Below) Grand Haven’s Kathryn Ackerman swims to her third-straight title in the 200 IM. (Click for more from HighSchoolSportsScene.com.)

Dow's Newman Right at Home in Water

By Paul Costanzo
Special for MHSAA.com

August 29, 2018

Claire Newman described her younger self as “a complete amphibian,” and not much has changed as she goes through her teenage years.

“I’ve just always felt at home in the water,” the Midland Dow junior said. “It helps me work out my school day and any emotional problems. Being in swim also kind of reminds me of my abilities and, personally, I feel more spiritually sound when I swim.”

Newman is a four-time Division 2 Finals runner-up, having placed second in the 50 and 100-yard freestyles both of the past two seasons. She has won state titles in club competition, and is already drawing interest from college swim programs at all levels.

So it’s no surprise she feels comfortable in the water. It’s an offseason spent mostly on dry land, however, that could be the catalyst for Newman’s strongest season yet.

“I spent two to three months doing physical therapy on my shoulder,” Newman said. “I feel much better now that my shoulder is all healed up. I know better how to prevent another injury. I’m already starting to see the results of it. I’m much more conscious of which muscles I’m using for every part of my stroke, but especially my shoulders.”

The shoulder injury surfaced during Newman’s sophomore season, and she said it was the result of overuse. While still in season, she trained by simply kicking in the pool for two weeks.

Newman managed to perform well when it mattered at the Division 2 meet, also helping Dow touch third in the 400-yard freestyle relay in addition to her runner-up individual finishes. But she said the entire process was tough emotionally.

She would go on to compete in Junior Nationals in Tennessee following the prep season, but eventually focused on getting healthy.

“She was working very hard on the dry-land aspect, then she started swimming again full-time in May and swam through the summer,” Dow coach Chilly Smith said. “She did very little swimming in January through April. It’s going to help her, hopefully, stay healthy. By doing all the dry land, she stabilized (her shoulder). That was probably the first time she’s ever had really four months out of the pool since she was younger -- a lot younger. I think it was good for her, and that’s why we brought her back fairly slow.”

Now healthy, Newman is ready to meet the goals she’s set for herself. While they’re lofty, they look to be well within her reach.

“I think winning an event at state is probably one of my goals,” she said. “Breaking 23 (seconds) officially in the 50 -- I’ve sort of, kind of done it unofficially. I want personal improvement in my other strokes, specifically the breaststroke and the butterfly, and I also want to get more college exposure.”

Based on last year’s results, Newman appears to be the favorite to complete her first goal – something she was on track to do a year ago.

In 2016, Newman finished second to Birmingham Seaholm’s Haley Doan in the 50 and Dexter’s Annette Schultz in the 100. She passed both of them in 2017, but East Grand Rapids’ move to Division 2 (from Division 3) brought into her races Ileah Doctor, who went on to set meet records in both events in finishing ahead of Newman. Doctor graduated this spring and will be swimming at Indiana University, but Newman’s motivation remains the same.

“I was aware of how incredibly fast she was,” Newman said. “I didn’t really focus on her as competition, though. I usually use myself as competition, trying to beat my own times and focus more on improving myself.

“I wasn’t waking up every morning thinking about Ileah Doctor. I was waking up every morning thinking about how I could get better.”

Winning an MHSAA Finals title, and breaking 23 seconds, would go a long way toward achieving Newman’s final goal of attracting more college attention. So would improving her other strokes and proving she can win at longer distances, as Newman is well aware.

“A lot of colleges really like to see a 200 (yard) swimmer,” Newman said. “That signals that you’re pretty flexible in your events, same with the two (individual medley events). I think it’s also really great for aerobic training.”

Smith said he’ll be working the longer events, as well as the butterfly, into Newman’s competitive schedule this season to help her and the team.

“A swimmer has to be able to swim different events, because that’s one way you can keep a swimmer from becoming stale or bored with their swimming,” he said. “We’re really trying to work the 200, because if we can get a better 200 out of her, that’s just going to help her 100 freestyle.”

Newman has taken a visit to Michigan State University and said that Notre Dame (which she has visited on her own) and Indiana also interest her significantly, as does Division III Kenyon College in Ohio. While she admits she wants to swim against Division I competition, the most important factor for Newman is finding the right academic fit, as well as an athletic one. She plans to study something in liberal arts that allows her to tap into her creative side.

No matter where she goes, as long as she’s in the water, she’ll be right at home.

Paul Costanzo served as a sportswriter at The Port Huron Times Herald from 2006-15, including three years as lead sportswriter, and prior to that as sports editor at the Hillsdale Daily News from 2005-06. He can be reached at [email protected] with story ideas for Genesee, Lapeer, St. Clair, Sanilac, Huron, Tuscola, Saginaw, Bay, Arenac, Midland and Gladwin counties.

PHOTOS: (Top) Midland Dow’s Claire Newman prepares to swim the 50-yard freestyle at last season’s Lower Peninsula Division 2 Finals at Holland Aquatic Center. (Middle) Newman, middle, looks to the scoreboard with her teammates in anticipation of their relay time. (Click to see more from HighSchoolSportsScene.com.)